Kanya Vidya Dhan
Berojgari Bhatta
Laptop distribution
Ambulances launch
Investor summit
VIP visits
Not judged on systemic changes but on events
This is a collection of my thoughts and ideas on various issues borne out of my experiences. The experiences are from more than 20 years of my professional life in IAS (Indian Administrative Service) in UP, India and also from my personal life. The views are personal.
Kanya Vidya Dhan
Berojgari Bhatta
Laptop distribution
Ambulances launch
Investor summit
VIP visits
Not judged on systemic changes but on events
In British times, officers/inspectors were British/paid by British and citizens were Indians. The purpose was to rule. So in any law, the enforcement powers were with the government Inspectors/officers/subordinate staff. They were assumed to be good and citizens bad. This was Inspector Raj.
But even 70 years after freedom, why do we make acts in the same way? If the purpose of any act is predominantly the benefit of all citizens and to discourage a minority of irresponsible ones from wrong behaviour, why not empower fellow law abiding citizens to partially enforce the law.
Substatntial powers may be misused by the citizens also. But the power to point out, power to take pictures and power to report the wrong behaviour/crime can be given to citizens for acts like ban on polythene, gutkha, pan masala, liquor, speeding, drunken driving.
Even in CrPC, there is a section which empowers a citizen to make an arrest in certain cases.
Without citizen being officialy empowered, the above noted actions would amount to intrusion into privacy of others. But right of privacy should be available to be enjoyed only by law abiding citizens not law violators.
Recently I came across a legislation in which I saw the game of snake and ladder taking place. There were so many unexpected pushes and pulls in the whole process.
A policy/legislation has to pass through so many stages (more than 100?) officially and some unofficially. Some of them may turnout to be extra fast and some extra slow.
I am wondering whether there are any case studies documenting the whole process (both official and unofficial).